Life is short, we might as well eat dessert first! Check out our current flavors, locations and find your new favorite obsession.
Sweet Things Are Happening
THE BEST DESSERT
You can find a little slice of heaven thanks to Pixie Pies! From our storefront to many of your favorite local Northeast Indiana restaurants, we're serving up delicious, decadent desserts. Planning a party, wedding, or special event? We'd love to help! Our catering and special orders are the perfect way to make any celebration extra sweet.
It's Pixie Pies
Sweetness is closer than you think! Find a little piece of heaven at our storefront or at our wonderful partners all over Northeast Indiana
Locations
From weddings to corporate events, make your gathering stand out with a custom order from Pixie Pies.
Catering
Get ready to indulge! Our menu is full of creamy, dreamy cheesecakes and other treats waiting to be devoured.
Menu
"Today was grand opening and I'm so happy I heard about this place! The owner is so sweet. The shop is so cute. Her cheesecake is phenomenal! Seriously so creamy and flavorful. I got german chocolate, fruity pebbles, and strawberry crunch. Make the trip if you're from Fort Wayne. It's delicious ❤️"
Natalie
Christa B.
"Pixie Pies have the absolute best cheesecakes I have had. Ashley always has fun & unique flavors to try! I look forward to the minis each week, and shevis so sweet to work with! Thanks Ashley, I'm looking forward to having you in Avilla!"
2/5
Bobbie H.
"Pixie Pies makes the most amazing cheesecakes! Perfect for desserts and parties! My husband was surprised to have not one but three delicious favors of cheesecakes for his birthday! Everyone who came very much enjoyed them!!! Can't wait to stop in for a slice or two, maybe three!"
3/5
Lisa L.
"Thee absolute best cheesecake I've ever had. It is hard for me to decide which flavor to choose when ordering!!! If you have not tried Pixie Pies yet, you need to add it to your bucket list. 5 STARS!!!!!!"
4/5
Karina M.
"Ashley and her crew are AMAZING.
My family and I all enjoy her cheesecakes (so many flavor options!) She’s the sweetest and I love how I’ve grown a friendship with my cheesecake lady ❤️
You will not be disappointed."
5/5
reese's and strawberry crunch
Heath Toffee
come visit our store front
strawberry crunch
strawberry crunch, key lime, root beer, and pistachio
strawberry crunch
raspberry oreo, cookie monster, turtle, red velvet
reese's, coffee espresso, butter pecan, and cherry
raspberry lemon and mississippi mud
Forget the fuss and let us whisk your guests away to dessert heaven! Whether it's a birthday bash, a corporate shindig, or a dreamy wedding, our delightful mini pies and sweet treats are guaranteed to be the talk of the town. We bake joy into every bite, making your event effortlessly enchanting.
Let Pixie Pies Handle the Sweetest Part of Your Party!
Sprinkle Some Magic on Your Next Event!
